Best Italian Restaurant in East Rutherford

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in East Rutherford, NJ at 119 Park Ave

Wood-fired pizza, made with gusto

Order online

Wood-fired, homemade Italian-American food

Pizza from the oven, chicken parm, Seafood Fra Diavolo — made with fresh ingredients and real care.

See our menu

The dining room in East Rutherford

Warm light, a glass ceiling, and tables set for whoever you're bringing tonight.

Made from scratch, every day

Parties and private events

The party room fits up to 60 guests. Great for birthdays, rehearsal dinners, corporate dinners, and more.

Plan your event

What our guests are saying

Don't sleep on this place. The food was absolutely delicious. Portions are generous. Our waitress was fun and engaging. The owner was super helpful and friendly. But the star of the show was my veal Milanese, so tender I was able to cut it with a fork.

Marta T.

First, I'm visiting this place. We saw it on United bonus miles with our Chase card. Wish we would have stopped in earlier. Everything was excellent. The salmon with the risotto was spectacular along with the shrimp over fresh spinach, the appetizers, the PEI muscles and the arugula salad were very good. A nice beautiful piece of cheesecake to finish it off with some great service. Thank you

Justin D.

While visiting from out of town we stumbled upon Gusto. They sat us with 30 min left til close and took such great care of us. We were the only party there as it was late and the server was an absolute sweetheart! Very nice and cozy inside. We ordered the rigatoni bolognese as well as the special pizza 3 pigs with hot honey. It was very good! The Caesar salad was also fantastic! If we ever find ourselves in NJ we will definitely comeback!

Armin S.

Great place, everything was on point. Calamari was amazing! And the fried Rainbow Cookie desert is uniquely delicious!! The prices were reasonabe for the complete package: appetizer, entree, dessert and coffee, which was a nice surprise!

Susan A.